The scene
Strategy Club · Friendly tournamentThe club trophy was temporarily awarded to whoever defeated Ivet. That person put it away before the final photograph.
The three players played one match per pair. The results sheet got wet, but the final standings and one match result survived.
What we know for certain
One of these people put away the trophy under the award rule: whoever defeated Ivet. Each pair played exactly once. A win is worth three points, a draw one per person and a loss zero. There were no withdrawals, penalties or bonus points.
The three accounts
Ivet Sol
Player«I finished the tournament with three points.»
Jofre Mas
Player«My total was also three.»
Kira Font
Player«All three of us finished level on points.»
Examine the evidence
0 of 5 openedOpening these five clues does not cost points.
01The complete schedule
Exactly these matches were played: Ivet–Jofre, Ivet–Kira and Jofre–Kira. Each person played two matches.
02The totals
All three finished with three points each. No results are missing and no matches remain to be played.
03The surviving result
The report confirms that Ivet beat Jofre. It was neither a draw nor a loss awarded through a penalty.
04The temporary award
The trophy was given to the only person who defeated Ivet in the tournament. The camera shows that person putting it away afterwards.
05Continuity
Nobody lent or transferred the trophy after receiving it. The missing trophy is the one from that presentation, not a replica.